Wednesday, July 23, 2008

New Friends

Later in the day we visited students studying at Humboldt University as part of the Leo Baeck Summer Institute. There were students who are studying Jewish Studies in Germany post-WWII. They are from all over the world and may are not Jewish, a huge surprise to me!

I first started talking to this guy, Mihai, who is not Jewish and from Romania. He told me he is studying in Bucharest and is from a "touristy" town on the Black Sea. I told him my father's side of the family is from Romania but left well over 100 years ago. He said they probably left between 1880 and 1902 because there was a large wave of Jewish emigration then. Hmm, yea, I thought. Has to be! Then I said my last name is Foreman and he said, "yes, Fuhrman - I do know someone whose last name is Fuhrman in my town and he is Jewish. How totally funny. I wonder if we are related. The best part was that I found out that he is studying anti-Semitism in Eastern Europe, at which point, my eyes lit up and I told him that I work for ADL. He seems so cool - I was blown away. After he finishes his degree in Bucharest, he wants to study in Israel.

I also met another student named Karol, who is a Polish Catholic studying International Affairs. I asked him if what was said was true, that there is a lot of anti-Semitism in Poland. He prefaced it by saying that he is not a patriotic Polish person, who was raised Catholic, but now denounces Catholicism. He said that anti-Semitism is very much classic anti-Semitism and people hold many typical anti-Semitic stereotypes. People deny it, but it still happens in the classic sense (Jews are cheap, rule the world, big noses, etc., etc.). He said that even though the Nazis orchestrated the Holocaust, the Poles had a lot to do with what happened. I asked, "they were the tools?" and he said, "yes, well, more. They took the initiative." He said even after the Holocaust when Jews came back to Poland to reclaim their homes and property, there were terrible pogroms.

I later asked him why he denounces Catholicism. He said that he doesn't like that the Priesthood is Celbate, and that this frustration causes pedophilia. Interesting theory. He says it is a hypocritical, chauvinistic religion. He doesn't like that women are seen as workers and not equals. Really incredible and intelligent guy. A little on the liberal side, though...

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Revelation

This morning we went to the Jewish cemetery at Schonhauser Alle and it differed significantly from the cemetery we visited the day before. Yesterday's was where Moses Mendelsohn was buried. That cemetery was not well preserved and even though it was a Jewish cemetery, it had been ruined and vandalized several times - also since there were so many bodies and dead people - not necessarily Jews during WWII they just needed to bury people to avoid the spread of diseases. So they buried many people in mass graves. Wild grass and weeds had grown throughout. The trees inside were not healthy, clearly diseased. It was striking at first at how unhealthy the ground was there, but I talked about it with Deborah and she pointed out clearly that people had been buried without coffins and the ecosystem was not right. Our guide, Carolyn, said that the Jewish community maintains it, but there really is not enough money to preserve it adequately.

Visiting the cemetery at Schonhauser Alle was strikingly different. This was the Jewish community's cemetery starting in the 1600's and became full in the 1880's. These were people who lead full-fledged thriving lives in Germany long before the Holocaust. This cemetery was quite beautiful. It was full of rows of graves with ivy flowing all over. Clearly very overgrown, but that added to its beauty. I was really moved with how beautiful it was. Moreover, it made me realize that it is so important to still go to Germany.


Two people in my life, one in her 70's and the other in her 90's, had a strong feeling that they could never go to Germany. We need to keep and remember the Jews who lived and died somewhat normal lives just as we remember those who died in the Holocaust. A life is a life and we cannot allow memorializing the Holocaust and the bitterness of Germany's past to stop us from remembering the beauty of those who came before. The day before, we visited the Neue Synagogue and learned about the archives that have been kept on the Jewish community from generations leading up to the Holocaust. Seeing that this vast archive of records exists on such an organized level and that they are actively working with other archives to add to the story - to complement what they know. Piece by piece they are trying to reconstruct Jewish life.

Gutenmorgen from Berlin!

From: Elizabeth Foreman [mailto:elizforeman@gmail.com]
Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2008 3:10 AM
Subject: Gutenmorgen from Berlin
- Hide quoted text -

Good morning from Berlin!

I am having an incredible time so far. Let me first start by saying that I have noticed some cultural differences: the German keyboard is different... the y and the z are switched and there seems to be an extra key to the right of the shift, so now that I have said that, please forgive anz y or z switches...

I arrived Fridaz morning and straight off the terminal, I felt a tight feeling in mz chest as I heard an announcement in German. It was a beautiful voice announcing some plane departure information for another flight. Even though I knew I was in Germany, it immediatelz reminded me of a Holocaust movie. This was definitelz something I was afraid would happen, since one of mz main associations with Germanz was teh Holocaust and all that has been done to memorialiye it through teh zears. I was verz fortunate to have someone from mz trip, Sara, also on mz flight. As we were waiting for our bags, Sara actuallz whispered teh exact same sentiment in mz ear.
A few dazs later I have gotten over the Holocaust association and am enjozing hearing the German I hear. I gavge up trzing to phoneticallz pronounce each word but have now adopted a German accent and am pronouncing everz word in sight. Mz favorite word is Kurferfurstendamm, which happens to be teh street we are staying on, known as the 'Fifth Avenue' of Berlin. It has some similar stores, although, not quite as upscale. You can see 2 H&Ms from my hotel and a Zara, though, along with some other interesting European stores. I have done no shopping zet, though, wohoo!

I have been to several museums... the Museum Bergreun (Picasso Museum), Dali Museum and the Checkpoint Charlie Museum, all of which have been cool. It is impossible to avoid hthe holocaust historz in this citz. we have seen countless memorials. The citz is full of recentlz constructed buildings, not to mention manz manz manz buildings currentlz under construction.
As for the reason Iäm hear.... Germanz Close Up! mz trip.. to explain the trip, I will send zou to the website www.germanycloseup.de but can give a bit of mz own experience so far. The first night at dinner we heard from a man named Karsten Voigt who works in Transatlantic Affairs for the German government. Basicallz the program was his brainchild. The program is funded bz the German government as a result of teh Marshall Plan. For those of zou who donät remember from 11th grade US historz, the Marshall Plan essentiallz paid to rebuild Europe (or specificallz Germanz) after WWII. So now, Germanz, is repazing its debt to teh US. I was blown awaz to hear this and reallz cannot express how moved I am to be a part of the Marshall Plan over 60 zears later.

Mz group is leaving in 10 minutes to visit a Jewish cemetarz and laetr meet some zoung German students for a scavenger hunt around the citz. the program has been amaying, powerful, upsetting, fun, exciting all in one. I wish I had more time to write more... hopefullz I can write again. The good news is the people on mz trip are amaying and besides the great program content, I can honestlz saz teh people are making it. Besides being cool, interesting and mature people, all are verz intelligent.

Hope all is well in the states!

Love,
Liy

Monday, July 21, 2008

Journey

Yesterday I tried to write an entry, but was unsuccessful. Trying to write now. Yesterday we went to a memorial for Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev, whose bodies were returned to Israel in exchange for a Hezbollah prisoner. We went a memorial service at the Judische Gemeinde. First a woman spoke in German and then there was a prayer by a rabbi. I felt like I was a part of it when I heard Hebrew. I got chills when the rabbi started to recite Yahrzeit. Everyone chimed in and it was powerful that despite whatever language we spoke, Hebrew is the common space. It was also the site of a concrete Holocaust Memorial wall. It listed several camps and there was a flame that must have already been lit. The symbolism between that wall behind and the fact that they were commemorating - memorializing - two Israeli soldiers is striking. In my mind, Israel came after Germany it is hard to rationalize German Jews grieving over the death of Israeli soldiers. Before this trip I never really put much thought to the current Jewish community in Germany. And the strange contradiction of Jews in Germany memorializing Israeli soldiers really made me think. I have been taught certain things, but never really reinforced to the fact that Jews stayed in Europe following the Holocaust. These are small communities and largely ignored by the mass of the Jewish community. There are a lot of similarities between the Jewish community I know and the one today in Germany. It has changed through the decades since the end of the war, but honestly, it still goes along with the same notion that they want Jewish survival and human survival. I suppose the basics have not really changed.

The Jewish community has to move on and embrace life wherever it may be. They did not abandon Germany; however, the promise for Zion was still with them wherever we are. Am Yisrael Chai and we are one, regardless of place.

Wansee Villa

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Final_Solution

Right now we're at the place where The Final Solution was discussed. The Final Solution was a meeting of the leaders of the Nazi Party in the Wansee Villa just outside of Berlin. At this meeting, the Nazi leaders discussed the plan to exterminate the Jews of Europe.

It is a really beautiful house overlooking the river. It is really striking how beautiful the house is and the marble pillars and marble fire place are. It was a really intense museum in the sense that it had constant words and quotes and historical text about the ideas and events leading up to this decision. It boggles my mind that human beings can still have a conversation about exterminating people, as if they are bugs. To be here and see how regal this place is put in the context that the men of the Third Reich were truly politicians and government people and police and truly decided the fate of millions in one room. I just don't understand how something like that could happen. The physical beauty and tranquility of the villa pissed me off. I have visited a few mansions and palaces and I now realize that these men were staying here and meeting as a retreat from their normal government offices. They lived their lives in luxury and arbitrarily decided in such a beautiful place the fate of millions.

Reading the information and quotes hit me, but it got emotional when I read quotes by survivors and grandchildren of survivors. It put a real face and name and context. The bulk of the exhibit was in black and white, but these quotes were in blue. The color showed hope and light.

Sunday, July 20, 2008

Germany's Contradiction

Tonight we settled into our first dinner together as a group. The program is funded by the German Foreign Ministry. The very interesting thing is that as a result of the Marshall Plan, Germany is now "repaying" its debt to America through this program. I feel amazed to be a part of history. I know nothing will ever ever ever make the Holocaust OK, but the Germans are truly owning up to their responsibilities. I feel so honored to be a part of this program. I feel so honored to have a place in this history.

With that, we heard from a representative of the German government who works in Transatlantic relations and focuses on German-American relations. He was quite fascinating - introducing himself by saying that he was born in 1941 and then following to say that anti-Semitism was never OK in his household. He apparently attended the Auschwitz trial. We covered a lot of topics like the place of the two largest minority groups - former Soviet Jews and Turks. Lots of issues have arisen. Beyond this, we somehow got onto the topic of Iran. I know - I asked him about his projects. Even though he works on the American-German relations, most of his work is not bilateral. He does a lot of work with America, Germany, and other countries, including Iran, Israel and many others. And so I asked what was the conversation like about Iran. He voiced that America went into Iraq to get to Iran, but perhaps that was the wrong order. I asked if Germany talks with Iran and he said yes. Apparently, according to him, America sees Iran and namely Ahmadinejad's words as a threat of nuclear capabilities. Germany sees it more nuanced - less that anything will actually happen. I questioned him on the Holocaust denial issue. I questioned him about the nuclear weapons more, but sort of ceded that perhaps Germany is naive when it comes to Iran. Regarding Holocaust denial, I asked if when he talks with Iranian officials, does he mention their denial of the Holocaust, especially in light of how much Germany has taken ownership of the genocide that they commited. He stated and reiterated that Iran and namely Ahmadinejad is very ideological and what he says in theory is not necessarily how others in government act. This concerned me, though, because in the public arena he denies it happened. I don't understand how a country that has done so much to take ownership for the Holocaust can then trust the two-faced government.

If Ahmadinejad's ideology is not the practice of others in government, then what is? I am concerned for how soft Germany is on Iran. He even said straight out - the German people see Ahmadinejad's words similarly to the discourse before WWII. Should that not be a red flag? Clearly Germany, of all countries, ought to tell Iran no. Iran, take Germany's mistake and stop. Germany perpetrated the murder of 11 million people and they say Iran is now only talking in ideological terms? Mein Kampf was written in ideological terms. So was the Final Solution. And then it came into fruition.

I don't want to let it seem like it was a bad dinner with him. It was very interesting and thought-provoking. However, he was a seasoned politician and clearly redirected my tougher questions well. It's taken my after-thought processing to really see what was lacking and what was truly troubling about that conversation.

So that was day 1 of the program. Goodnight!

Berlin Beginnings

The program officially started this afternoon, but I arrived in Berlin on Friday morning. My flight was at 7 PM on Thursday night from NY and it was pretty uneventful. I was lucky that I had Sara on my flight and a familiar face since a bunch of the NYers all met last Saturday night at Adam's apartment on the UWS. Once Sara and I got to the hotel, we had a note from Eryn who I had known was also coming early. Sara, Eryn and I all wanted to immediately explore Berlin. We ran into Deborah and Rivky, who we also met last Saturday night. They were going to get kosher food for Shabbat. Sara, Eryn and I went to try to find some fashion week events, since it happens to be Berlin Fashion Week July 17 - 20. We also made it to the Brandenburg Gate, which there was no access to while the Berlin Wall was up. We saw a bunch of embassies - American, French and British, which all have a prime location because they were built soon after the wall fell. They all had first dibs. We then found our way into some public gallery space which had really cool pop art. We saw some cool fashion week stuff in a gallery - stands with designer-like clothing. The fun part of it all was the adventure of public transportation. We bought an all-day pass for a group and used buses and trains, although you do not need to punch it in on the train. It's on an honor system and well, the next day Eryn and I just used our pass from the day before... Anyway, eventually after my guidebook got us lost, we made it to Kreuzberg, which is in East Berlin. We got to the Turkish market, which was awesome. All the Turkish men yelling prices out at you and fresh fruit stand after fresh fruit stand. Everyone offering you to try samples. Random people picking a grape or a cherry to taste. The prices were also very good. It was a fun experience to be in a hectic, pushy at times, atmosphere where the men at the stands didn't speak English and we didn't speak German or Turkish. I ate a cool thing that was a hot square of filo dough that had spinach and cheese in it. The next day was today - Saturday - Sara, Rivky and Deborah did Shabbat stuff. Eryn and I took off the Picasso Museum - Museum Bergruen, which was cool because it had Picassos from his various stages in life. I really liked the portraits the best. He also had some Henri Matise. Paul Klee and one other artist. We checked Schloss Charlottenberg, which is a castle of a German Queen, whose husband built it for her as a retreat. I was a little disappointed by the castle because it was said to be done in the style of Versailles but the building grounds didn't seem to be kept up so well. After that we went to the Checkpoint Charlie Museum, which highlights people who escaped the Berlin Wall (were able to sneak through). It was cool, but very disorganized. It was a lot of pictures and words all at once. After, Eryn and I found an outfoor area right next to the path of the wall, which basically told the story going back to the Potsdam Conference. We should have read it before we went in! Nonetheless, it was very cool to refresh my knowledge of that history and to stand where the wall once stood. We travelled back to the hotel because the program was actually about to begin.